Tuesday, November 12, 2024

Book 25: The Butcher of the Forest by Premee Mohamed

Book club book! This novella has a setup that's pretty classic: two children, the daughter and son of the ruler of a land, have gone into a forest that humans do not escape from, and the ruler asks a woman who has been there before to retrieve them for him. But the specifics throughout the story are much more complicated than the standard telling: the ruler is the Tyrant, who has caused the death of the woman's mother and father, and while she did succeed at bringing a child back before, the child never recovered. This is a request that Veris cannot refuse, and if she fails, it will be mean the death of her village and the only family she has left. 

This was a very easy read that pulled me right along, and it's a story that doesn't hold your hand overexplaining things, which I really like as a narrative choice and also fits the sort of arbitrary world both within and without the forest. Bad things happen, in the woods and in the village and in the larger world, and all you can do is keep going. (It is possible that I am bringing something of my own mood to this story in the second week of November 2024.) I could have done with an ending that gave me a few more answers or even just hints for the direction of the future, but I don't think that's what the author wanted, so fair enough! Ambiguity isn't always a flaw, even if I could do with a bit more certainty right now. 

Grade: B