A book club book! At the last minute my work schedule cleared just enough for me to read this in time for my May book club, and I'm glad it did! It was the perfect length for that kind of turnaround - this novella is a very quick, enjoyable read.
This story is a real blend of genres and tropes - it's got flavors of the Old West frontier standing in as a sort of liminal space for both the Elite and the Fallen, two kinds of people who either have divinity or do not. Angels and demons are real and walk among the humans, and the story centers on Celeste and Mariel. Both are Fallen but Celeste can pass as Elite, and that becomes very useful when Mariel is arrested for the murder of a Virtue and has to figure out how to prove her sister's innocence. There are saloon brawls and ex-lovers and secret lovers and so on and so forth, and it's very fun! I think I was hoping for a bit more from it overall than it gave; the world is interesting enough that I would have enjoyed a novel that fully fleshed out the elements of the society and the various characters living in the town. The end in particular didn't quite land the way I was hoping it might, and some of the tropes felt gestured at, rather than really developed. Someone at my book club said that it felt a bit like a pandemic book to her, and that felt right to me. Perfectly enjoyable, but not exceptional.
Grade: B
No comments:
Post a Comment